Economy | 19 Nov 26, 00:00
Gibraltar's property market has no shortage of asking prices. Open any property portal and there are apartments, townhouses and commercial properties available across the Rock, with prices for everyone to scrutinise.
But there is a fundamental problem: asking prices are not selling prices, and the distinction matters more than many people realise.
Buyers can see what vendors hope to achieve, but they cannot easily see what properties are actually selling for. They can compare advertised prices, look at neighbouring developments and monitor how long a property has been online. Yet much of the information that would help them make an informed decision remains out of reach.
This lack of transparency is not simply an inconvenience. It is contributing to unrealistic expectations, poor decision-making and a market that could be working considerably better.
One of the recurring problems in Gibraltar is how asking prices are established in the first place.
Rather than always being based on a thorough assessment of comparable transactions and current market conditions, some asking prices are heavily influenced by what the vendor wants to achieve. An agent may ask an owner what they hope to achieve and, rather than providing firm professional advice, agree to market the property at that figure.
This is not necessarily a case of agents deliberately overvaluing properties to win instructions. It is often a reluctance to challenge a vendor's expectations in the first place. Maybe a lack of professionalism in the industry, or maybe just straight up incompetance.
The result can be asking prices that have little relationship to what a willing buyer is actually prepared to pay.
The problem is compounded by the way people assess their own properties. Owners naturally believe their home is better than the one next door. They see a neighbouring property advertised at a particular price, assume theirs is superior and add a little more.
But the neighbouring property's asking price tells them very little about its actual value. It may be overpriced itself, and there is no guarantee it will ever sell for anything close to the advertised figure.
Without reliable information about completed transactions, the cycle continues. Asking prices become the reference point for other asking prices, rather than being grounded in what buyers are genuinely paying.
Buyers are increasingly able to see how long a property has been advertised. That visibility has changed the market considerably.
Twenty years ago, a property could remain on an estate agent's books without the entire buying public necessarily knowing about it. Today, online portals mean that anyone can search the market and see properties that have been advertised for months, or even years.
A vendor might believe they are being strong by holding out for their desired price. In reality, an unrealistic asking price can be completely counterproductive.
Once a property has been online for a long time, buyers can begin to assume there is something wrong with it. They may conclude that it is overpriced, has an undisclosed problem or that the vendor is difficult to deal with.
That perception can persist even when the circumstances have changed.
There is also an issue with how listing histories are displayed. On PropertyGibraltar.com, for example, no date of reduction is displayed. A property might have been advertised for a year and reduced four times, but a buyer may only see that it has been online for a year at its current price.
The buyer may not appreciate that the vendor has already adjusted their expectations. They simply remember the property and how long it has been available.
It is also not uncommon to find listings that remain online after a property has been sold, let or withdrawn. Whether through poor administration or a desire to generate further enquiries, these outdated listings distort the picture of what is genuinely available.
The result is a property portal that may show plenty of activity without necessarily providing an accurate reflection of the market.
The internet has undoubtedly made property information more accessible. Buyers can browse almost the entire advertised market from their phones, compare properties and monitor asking prices without speaking to an estate agent.
But this can create a false sense of knowledge.
Seeing an asking price does not tell a buyer what a property is worth. It does not reveal what similar homes have actually sold for, how much their prices have been reduced, or whether transactions are taking place in the same building or development.
In many respects, buyers have access to more information than ever before, but not necessarily the information they need.
This is why greater transparency around completed sale prices would make such a difference.
In the UK, services such as Rightmove's sold-price search allow the public to look up historical property transactions and see what homes have actually sold for.
Gibraltar would benefit enormously from something comparable.
A publicly accessible record of completed sale prices would give vendors a much clearer understanding of market values. Instead of basing expectations on what a neighbour is asking, owners could look at genuine transactions in their own street, block or development.
Buyers would benefit too. They could see that properties are selling locally, understand the prices being achieved and make offers with greater confidence.
Importantly, transparency is not about forcing prices down. It is about allowing the market to operate with better information.
There are understandable concerns about making more information public, particularly from those who believe that greater transparency could make negotiations more difficult. However, protecting information does not necessarily protect the market. In the longer term, uncertainty can be far more damaging.
A market in which buyers and sellers have confidence is more likely to generate transactions than one in which everyone is guessing.
Estate agents have an important responsibility in all of this.
A professional agent should be prepared to give honest advice, even when that advice is not what a vendor wants to hear. If a property is overpriced, that needs to be explained clearly, supported by evidence and discussed openly.
Simply agreeing with an owner's expectations to secure an instruction does not serve the vendor's interests. Nor does it help buyers or the wider market.
Gibraltar needs agents who are prepared to challenge unrealistic expectations, provide proper market guidance and prioritise the successful sale of a property over simply accumulating listings.
There is also a responsibility for the main property portals to ensure that the information they display is accurate.
PropertyGibraltar.com, as Gibraltar's principal property portal, could take a more proactive approach to outdated listings. A straightforward annual renewal process would be a sensible starting point.
For example, when a property reaches 12 months online, the portal could automatically remove it and contact the listing agent to confirm whether it remains available. The agent could instantly reinstate the listing with a simple confirmation. If no action is taken, the listing would automatically be removed.
The principle is simple: doing nothing should result in an outdated listing being removed, not remaining online indefinitely.
This practice was established by UK portals decades and and helps ensure that buyers are looking at genuine, current stock rather than a mixture of available properties and listings that should have disappeared months ago.
Ultimately, a lack of transparency does not just affect individual buyers and sellers. It affects the entire Gibraltar property market.
When buyers cannot establish whether prices are realistic, they become more cautious about making offers. When vendors cannot see what properties are actually achieving, they may be reluctant to put their own homes on the market at a sensible price.
Properties remain unsold, people delay moving and transactions that could have happened simply do not take place.
Greater transparency could help change that.
Buyers would have more confidence to make offers. Vendors would have a more realistic understanding of their property's value. Agents would be better equipped to provide meaningful advice, and the market would have a clearer picture of what is actually happening.
More transactions would also benefit the wider economy, creating activity for solicitors, surveyors, removal companies, tradespeople and other businesses connected to property. Increased economic activity can bring wider benefits, including additional tax revenue.
Gibraltar does not need more asking prices. It needs better information, greater accountability and a more professional approach to the way property is marketed.
A healthy property market depends on confidence. Confidence depends on transparency. And transparency should be something the Gibraltar property market is prepared to embrace, not avoid.